Editorial by Editor

Review and Herald Publishing Association · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Aug 4, 1910

Editorial

By Editor

A Gloomy Doctrine? — In the REVIEW of March 14, 1865, Elder J. N. Andrews suggested some thoughts to those who regarded the Bible doctrine of the sleep of the dead, between death and the resurrection, as a gloomy doctrine. He wrote:—

You say the doctrine is full of gloom; and that the departed saints have experienced a bitter disappointment in being consigned to the cold grave for long ages, instead of being received into glory. You think the idea full of gloom to the living, and dreadful to the dead. But you forget that if the doctrine be true, there is no chill, no gloom, no darkness, no disappointment, no lapse of time, no waiting through long ages, to the dead. The interval between their decease and their resurrection will to them be no time at all. The twinkling of an eye, in which the righteous will be changed to immortality, will be to them as long as the whole period will be to righteous Abel that he has slept in death. And to him, so far as his own knowledge of the case is concerned, it will be precisely as if he entered heaven the very moment he was slain.

You say that this helps the matter a little; but that, for all this, the sleep of the dead will no more compare in consolation with the soul's immortality and the reward at death, than the desert of Sahara will compare in beauty with the garden of Eden. Do not be too hasty, friends. You may discover facts that will change this opinion. You find great consolation in the thought that the soul is immortal, and that men are rewarded as soon as they die. Answer me a few questions: How large a part of mankind lead lives of holiness, and die with good evidence of their acceptance with God? Truth compels you to answer that a minority are all that can be said to do this. What becomes, then, of this great majority of men who have died out of Christ and entered their reward?—O, they have gone into the furnace of fire, where there is wailing and gnashing of teeth. What is the condition, then, at this very moment of the greater part of the dead, according to this cheering doctrine of yours? You have to answer, They are in unspeakable torment. You admit that this dreadful fact somewhat abates the consolation you have hitherto found in this doctrine. But I want you to answer one question more: If the soul is immortal, as you affirm, how long are these impenitent men thus to suffer? You answer again, and this time surely with a shudder, They must suffer to all eternity. Before we part, will you not own that yours is the gloomy doctrine? Is it not a relief to your mind to think that men are to be judged before they are rewarded or punished? and that till the day of Judgment, men wait for their reward? And is not that doctrine best which teaches that immortality is the gift of God, and that it is given only to the righteous?