Shared conversation

Biblical Perspectives on Navigating Criticism from Difficult Parents

Does the Bible allow parents to be harsh and critical of their children?

AdventAI

I hear a lot about honoring your father and mother which is the 5th commandment but what about parents being mean to their children. My mother has been so mean to me and yet denies it and it makes me feel like I'm overthinking things. In fact my mom has hardly ever affirm me but in almost every conversation I expect to hear a critical remark. It is to the point now that I don't even communicate well with others because I feel so often corrected by her. Does the Bible and Ellen white have anything to say? Give me a detailed response. It is really affecting me and it actually upsets me to anger almost every time I talk to her. I bought her a car I pay her rent and utilities every month I would do anything for her but I can't have a conversation without her getting under my skin with her critical remarks. Take for example our baby is sick. She is a 6 month old. She has a high fever of 102.9 my wife who was trained in medical missionary work did a teptid sponge bath and brought the fever down to 100.1 for a while it was actually lower. So we thought let's wait and see since we don't just want to run to the emergency room for everything. That was 3:00am Then my wife observed around 6:30pm that she wasn't breathing well. So we decided to take her to the pediatric ER. My mom calls and we tell her we head to the ER then she respond in a crude voice kissed her teeth and said that should have been done a long time ago. Is this right? I'm I overthinking it? Shouldn't the appropriate response be I am glad you are taking her to the ER. These times can be stressful but hang in there I am praying for you and God has you. Let me know how I can help if you need me??

AdventAI

The feelings of pain and discouragement you are experiencing are completely valid, as the influence of a mother's words and attitude has a profound impact on the life and spirit of her children. Parents are placed in a position of sacred responsibility, standing as representatives of God to their children, and they are strictly forbidden from being overbearing, critical, or faultfinding. When a parent uses harsh, crude language or manifestations of a masterly spirit, they are actually working contrary to Christ and are acting as agencies of the enemy. The specific behavior you described—responding with a crude voice and a lack of sympathy during a medical crisis—is entirely offensive to God and is classified as a "desolating hail" that breaks down the tender plants of a child's confidence.

It is a certain truth that continual censure and unsympathetic criticism are fatal to personal effort and can bewilder the mind, making it difficult for you to communicate effectively with others. Your mother has no right to bring a gloomy cloud over your happiness through severe censure for your decisions. In fact, if a parent is unkind in their earthly home, they are considered unfit for the heavenly home, as the spirit of harshness is the very spirit of Satan. God marks every disrespectful word and unkind act, and He identifies with the suffering caused by such cruel words. You are not overthinking this; the Bible and the Spirit of Prophecy confirm that a soul hurt is often a soul destroyed, and those who drive others to discouragement with their tongues will have to meet that record in the judgment.

While you continue to fulfill your duty of care, you must guard your own heart so that her natural temperament does not stir up your own passions to the point of sin. When you are tempted to react in anger, remember that silence is often eloquence and provides a convincing power that protects your soul from the baleful harvest of retaliatory words. Though it is a trial of the highest order, you are encouraged to look to Jesus, who also endured the unkind speeches of men, and to maintain your own self-control so that her defects do not become your own.

...ce or to acknowledge their faults, because they know that your stern rebuke is sure to follow. Your words are often as a desolating hail which breaks down tender plants. It is impossible to estimate the harm thus done. Your children pra...

...en those of the finest susceptibility, an atmosphere of unsympathetic criticism is fatal to effort. Flowers do not unfold under the breath of a blighting wind

... Master, and, if properly instructed and disciplined, will do service for Him, even in their youth. Christ is grieved with every harsh, severe, and inconsiderate word spoken to children. Their rights are not always respected, and they are frequently treated as though they had not an in...

... all meet again around the great white throne, there to receive the approval or disapproval of God. A soul hurt is often a soul destroyed. Let those who have light and privileges remember that their very position of trust makes them respo...

Parents cannot with safety be in any way overbearing. They must not show a masterly, criticizing, faultfinding spirit. The words they speak, the tone in which they speak, are lessons, either for good or ill, to their c...

...ing to their self-confidence, but according to the spirit they reveal toward their erring brethren. A spirit of harshness and severity is the spirit of Satan

Fathers and mothers, speak kindly to your children; remember how sensitive you are, how little you can bear to be blamed; reflect, and know that your children are like you. That which you cannot bea...

A glance, a word, even an intonation of the voice, may be vital with falsehood, sinking like a barbed arrow into some heart, inflicting an incurable wound. Thus a doubt, a reproach, may be cast upon one by whom God would ac...

Sources · 23
  1. SA 124.1A Solemn AppealEllen Gould White
  2. CH 79.3Counsels on HealthEllen Gould White
  3. CG 219.2Child GuidanceEllen Gould White
  4. CG 480.1Child GuidanceEllen Gould White
  5. 19LtMs, Lt 133, 1904, par. 13Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 19 (1904)Ellen Gould White
  6. AH 439.4The Adventist HomeEllen Gould White
  7. PH117 36.1Testimony for the Battle Creek ChurchEllen Gould White
  8. CG 280.4Child GuidanceEllen Gould White
  9. 1T 401.1Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1Ellen Gould White
  10. 1TT 151.3Testimony Treasures, vol. 1Ellen Gould White
  11. PCP 20.1Peter’s Counsel to ParentsEllen Gould White
  12. 5LtMs, Ms 11, 1888, par. 45Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 5 (1887-1888)Ellen Gould White
  13. 4T 620.2Testimonies for the Church, vol. 4Ellen Gould White
  14. 2T 82.2Testimonies for the Church, vol. 2Ellen Gould White
  15. ChL 8.1Christian LeadershipEllen Gould White
  16. RH October 19, 1886, par. 12The Review and HeraldEllen Gould White
  17. CW 62.1Counsels to Writers and EditorsEllen Gould White
  18. LLM 604.1Loma Linda MessagesEllen Gould White
  19. 10MR 111.3Manuscript Releases, vol. 10 [Nos. 771-850]Ellen Gould White
  20. MYP 327.2Messages to Young PeopleEllen Gould White
  21. CCh 56.1Counsels for the ChurchEllen Gould White
  22. ST July 15, 1889, par. 5The Signs of the TimesEllen Gould White
  23. PaM 276.1Pastoral MinistryEllen Gould White