Shared conversation

The Sabbath, Constantine, and the Venerable Day of the Sun

Was Constantine's first Sunday law actually a Christian decree?

AdventAI

What is the Sabbath?

AdventAI

The Sabbath is the holy seventh day of the week, which was established by God at the close of creation as a spiritual memorial of His work and a sign of sanctification between Him and His people Genesis 2:2-3. It is an original institution, made for the benefit of all humanity, that serves as a perpetual witness to the Creator who made the heavens and the earth Mark 2:27.

The Origin and Nature of the Sabbath

The Sabbath did not originate at Mount Sinai but was instituted in Eden before sin entered the world Genesis 2:1-3. God established it through three distinct acts:

  • He Rested: After creating the world in six days, God rested on the seventh day from all His work Genesis 2:2.

  • He Blessed it: God placed a special blessing upon the seventh day because He had rested upon it Genesis 2:3.

  • He Sanctified it: To sanctify the day means to set it apart for sacred use, making it the "holy of the Lord" Isaiah 58:13.

A Sign and Seal of God's Authority

The Sabbath is the "seal" of God's law because it reveals His identity as the Creator and His jurisdiction over the world.

  • A Sign of Sanctification: It serves as a sign that it is Jehovah who sanctifies His people and makes them holy Exodus 31:13.

  • A Distinction of Faith: Loyalty to the fourth commandment, which enjoins the seventh-day Sabbath, is the distinguishing feature of the faith of those who keep the commandments of God Revelation 14:12.

  • A Knowledge of God: Hallowing the Sabbath is a means by which people come to know that the Lord is their God Ezekiel 20:20.

The Sabbath Throughout History

The Sabbath is a permanent institution that has been recognized by the faithful in all ages:

  • Before the Law: Traces of the seven-day week appear throughout the patriarchal age, and the Sabbath was clearly enforced before the giving of the Decalogue at Sinai Genesis 7:4.

  • Jesus and the Apostles: Christ recognized the perpetuity of the Sabbath and taught that it was lawful to perform acts of mercy and necessity on His holy day Matthew 12:12. The apostles and primitive Christians continued to observe the seventh-day Sabbath long after the resurrection Acts 13:42-44.

  • The Last Conflict: In the final conflict between truth and error, the observance of the true Sabbath will be the pivot upon which the world's destiny turns. While the Papacy has sought to substitute a "spurious sabbath" (Sunday), God's people will exalt the true memorial of creation.

The Purpose of the Sabbath

The Sabbath is intended to be a delight and a day of spiritual restoration Isaiah 58:13-14. It is not a day for self-righteousness or mere form, but a day to rest in the perfect works of the Lord and to be refreshed by His presence Exodus 31:17. By setting aside our own works and honor, we find true rest in Him.

Sources · 21
  1. 15MR 39.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 15 [Nos. 1136-1185]Ellen Gould White
  2. RRCS 2.3A Review of the Remarks of O.R.L. Crozier on the Institution, Design and Abolition of the SabbathJohn Nevins Andrews
  3. SOSL 58.3Sermons on the Sabbath and the LawJohn Nevins Andrews
  4. BP2 117.4[Bates’ Pamphlet #2] Second Advent Way Marks and High HeapsJoseph Bates
  5. FEE 45.1From Eden to EdenJoseph Harvey Waggoner
  6. GCB/GCDB 1893, page 73.1General Conference Daily Bulletin, vol. 5Alonzo Trevier Jones
  7. SSP 132.2The Story of the Seer of PatmosStephen Nelson Haskell
  8. RH April 27, 1911, par. 12The Review and HeraldEllen Gould White
  9. 19MR 173.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 19 [Nos. 1360-1419]Ellen Gould White
  10. 4BC 1168.8EGW SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 4Ellen Gould White
  11. SITI December 22, 1887, page 775.2The Signs of the Times, vol. 13Alonzo Trevier Jones
  12. HSFD 39.1History of the Sabbath and First Day of the WeekJohn Nevins Andrews
  13. TDOC 201.7The Doctrine of ChristWilliam Warren Prescott
  14. SC1 38.1[Sabbath Controversy #1] The Seventh Day Sabbath, A Perpetual SignJoseph Bates
  15. ADTE April 1846, page 13.3The Advent Testimony, vol. 1 (partial)The Advent Testimony
  16. ChSa 90.3The Change of the SabbathGeorge Ide Butler
  17. HSFD 127.5History of the Sabbath and First Day of the WeekJohn Nevins Andrews
  18. 3MR 255.4Manuscript Releases, vol. 3 [Nos. 162-209]Ellen Gould White
  19. SITI December 23, 1886, page 776.1The Signs of the Times, vol. 12Alonzo Trevier Jones
  20. 4BC 1171.8EGW SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 4Ellen Gould White
  21. AMS July 14, 1898, page 422.5American Sentinel, vol. 13Ellet Joseph Waggoner

Why did Constantine become Christians?

AdventAI

Constantine’s profession of Christianity was a calculated move to turn the growing religious power of the church to his own political account. While he is often called the "first Christian emperor," his actions were characterized by a desire to make theology a branch of politics to strengthen his imperial authority.

Political and Military Ambitions

Constantine saw in the expanding Christian movement a force that could be harnessed for the stability of the Roman Empire.

  • Turning Power to His Account: He conceived the idea of utilizing this new religion, which was rapidly displacing paganism, as a tool for his own governance.

  • Alliance with Bishops: This was a mutual arrangement, as the bishops of the time were also grasping for civil power, aiming to make politics a branch of theology.

  • The Milvian Bridge: His victory over Maxentius was portrayed by church leaders like Eusebius as a divine deliverance, likening Constantine to a new Moses leading a new Israel.

The Timing of His Conversion

The historical record shows significant ambiguity regarding when, or even if, a true conversion occurred.

  • Varying Accounts: Different historians date his conversion to 306, 312, 321, 323, or 327, while some believe it only occurred at his deathbed baptism and others suggest he never truly became a Christian.

  • Continued Pagan Practices: Even after his "professed conversion," Constantine continued to support pagan customs. For example, the day after enacting his Sunday law in A.D. 321, he issued a law regulating the work of soothsayers who examined the entrails of sacrificed beasts.

  • Strategic Legislation: His famous Sunday law of A.D. 321 did not even use Christian terminology, but instead referred to "the venerable day of the sun," a name associated with heathen sun worship.

Religious Compromise and Control

Constantine's support of the church allowed him to exert immense control over its doctrines and practices.

  • Council of Nicea: He convened the Council of Nicea in A.D. 325 to resolve the Arian controversy, not necessarily out of spiritual concern, but to maintain unity within his empire.

  • Enforcement of Dogma: He confirmed the Nicene Creed and threatened those who would not subscribe to it with exile, elevating ecclesiastical decrees to the position of imperial laws.

  • Union of Church and State: By uniting the church with the secular arm, Constantine laid the foundation for a system where religious decrees were enforced by civil penalties. This union ultimately led to a period of great corruption and the development of the Papacy.

The Bible warns against the corruption that occurs when religious leaders seek worldly honor and power, as the true goal is to follow the faith of Jesus and the commandments of God Revelation 14:12. We are encouraged to remember that the "saints of the Most High" will eventually take the kingdom through God's power, not through political intrigue Daniel 7:16.

Sources · 18
  1. AMS July 12, 1894, page 217.3The American Sentinel 9Alonzo Trevier Jones
  2. AMS June 1886, page 43.4American Sentinel, vol. 1Ellet Joseph Waggoner
  3. SLOC 9.1Sunday LegislationAlonzo Trevier Jones
  4. GEP 424.1The Great Empires of Prophecy, from Babylon to the Fall of RomeAlonzo Trevier Jones
  5. DAR1909 433.2Daniel and The RevelationUriah Smith
  6. SYNPT 108.3Synopsis of the Present TruthUriah Smith
  7. TBI 165.2The Biblical InstituteUriah Smith
  8. SYNPT 108.5Synopsis of the Present TruthUriah Smith
  9. AMS January 28, 1897, page 52.10The American Sentinel 12Alonzo Trevier Jones
  10. ARSH March 22, 1864, page 132.16Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 23Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald
  11. HBS 131.10Handbook for Bible StudentsGeneral Conference of SDA
  12. BEST September 20, 1897, page 300.22The Bible Echo, vol. 12Alonzo Trevier Jones
  13. DAR1909 144.2Daniel and The RevelationUriah Smith
  14. AMS January 1888, page 4.3American Sentinel, vol. 3Ellet Joseph Waggoner
  15. AMS March 1887, page 19.7The American Sentinel 2Alonzo Trevier Jones
  16. ARSH October 2, 1860, page 159.6Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 16James Springer White
  17. ChSa 112.1The Change of the SabbathGeorge Ide Butler
  18. ARSH July 8, 1862, page 44.8Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 20James Springer White

the "venerable Day of the Sun" means?

AdventAI

The "venerable day of the sun" refers to Sunday, an ancient heathen festival day dedicated to the worship of the sun god, which Constantine eventually established as a legal day of rest to harmonize the pagan and Christian religions of the Roman Empire. This title was distinctively religious and pagan, as the sun was the chief object of heathen worship and the first day of the week was seen as an emblem of its generative power.

The Origin of the Title

The name is deeply rooted in ancient idolatry and solar worship:

  • Solar Worship: The sun was considered the bright image of God's benignity and glory by Eastern nations, who performed worship with their faces turned toward its rising beams.

  • A Pagan Memorial: Sunday was established as a standing memorial of the sun's veneration by the Egyptians, and later the Greeks and Romans, who conceiving the sun to have a divine body, dedicated the day to its honor.

  • Heathen Identification: Because of its ancient and universal observance by the pagan world, Sunday is frequently described as the "wild solar holiday of all pagan times".

Constantine’s Famous Edict (A.D. 321)

Constantine used this specific title in the first Sunday law ever enacted to ensure the decree would be acceptable to his pagan subjects.

  • The Language of the Law: The edict of March 7, A.D. 321, commanded that "all judges and city people and the craftsmen shall rest upon the venerable day of the sun".

  • Exclusion of Country Labor: Notably, the law permitted country people to continue agricultural pursuits, such as sowing grain and planting vines, so that the "bounty provided by Heaven" would not be lost.

  • A Pagan Act: At the time of this edict, Constantine was still a devoted worshiper of Apollo, the sun god, and his decree made no allusion to the day as a Christian institution or the "Lord's day".

The Transformation into a "Christian" Sabbath

Over time, the church adopted this pagan day and attempted to transform its character:

  • Union of Sentiment: The retention of the name "Sunday" is due to the union of pagan and Christian sentiment, as Constantine recommended the day to both classes alike to harmonize the discordant religions of the empire.

  • Ecclesiastical Sanction: Later, ambitious bishops and the Church of Rome sanctioned this "venerable day" as a Christian festival, eventually prohibiting the agricultural labor that Constantine had originally allowed.

  • Substitutions in the Law: Advocates of Sunday worship eventually struck the name of the Lawgiver and the seventh-day Sabbath from the fourth commandment, substituting this "venerable day of the sun" in its place.

The Bible warns against turning one's back on the true God to worship the sun, as such idolatry was a primary cause for the captivity of ancient Israel 2 Kings 23:5. True worship must be "in spirit and in truth," honoring the Creator on His sanctified seventh-day Sabbath rather than following the commandments of men John 4:24. God promises that "them that honor me I will honor, and they that despise me shall be lightly esteemed" 1 Samuel 2:30.

Sources · 25
  1. RCASDA 146.5Replies to Elder Canright’s Attacks on Seventh-day AdventistsUriah Smith
  2. SBBS 538.2Source Book for Bible StudentsGeneral Conference of SDA
  3. TDC May 12, 1889, page 4.14The Topeka Daily Capital, vol. 11Alonzo Trevier Jones
  4. ASLD 98.1The “Abiding Sabbath” and the “Lord’s Day”Alonzo Trevier Jones
  5. GEP 482.3The Great Empires of Prophecy, from Babylon to the Fall of RomeAlonzo Trevier Jones
  6. PTUK February 8, 1894, page 87.2The Present Truth, vol. 10Ellet Joseph Waggoner
  7. PTUK January 16, 1896, page 35.3The Present Truth, vol. 12Alonzo Trevier Jones
  8. ARSH July 21, 1859, page 67.2Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 14Uriah Smith
  9. SOSL 138.3Sermons on the Sabbath and the LawJohn Nevins Andrews
  10. ChSa 113.3The Change of the SabbathGeorge Ide Butler
  11. ChSa 96.5The Change of the SabbathGeorge Ide Butler
  12. PTUK September 7, 1893, page 358.11The Present Truth, vol. 9Ellet Joseph Waggoner
  13. AMS January 28, 1897, page 52.11The American Sentinel 12Alonzo Trevier Jones
  14. TCNA 26.5The Ten CommandmentsJoseph Harvey Waggoner
  15. GC 680.5The Great ControversyEllen Gould White
  16. BHB 83.3Bible HandbookStephen Nelson Haskell
  17. ASLD 98.3The “Abiding Sabbath” and the “Lord’s Day”Alonzo Trevier Jones
  18. CGRAS 85.1Civil Government and ReligionAlonzo Trevier Jones
  19. TFNOS 31.2The Truth FoundJoseph Harvey Waggoner
  20. ARSH July 28, 1859, page 73.14Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 14Uriah Smith
  21. OGSO 83.2The Origin and Growth of Sunday Observance in the Christian ChurchJoseph Harvey Waggoner
  22. GEP 429.1The Great Empires of Prophecy, from Babylon to the Fall of RomeAlonzo Trevier Jones
  23. SOSL 141.7Sermons on the Sabbath and the LawJohn Nevins Andrews
  24. ST September 14, 1882, par. 3The Signs of the TimesEllen Gould White
  25. OGSO 49.1The Origin and Growth of Sunday Observance in the Christian ChurchJoseph Harvey Waggoner