Esau Asks Jacob for the Red StewBible World

Genesis 25:29

And Jacob sod pottage: and Esau came from the field, and he was faint:

The verse pictures Jacob cooking pottage when Esau came in faint from the field, setting the scene where a valuable inheritance was traded to meet an immediate, passing need. Jacob turned that faint hunger to his own advantage, offering what he had cooked if Esau would renounce all claim as firstborn, and Esau sold his birthright and confirmed the sale with an oath. Esau's appetite, long indulged until it ruled him and overpowered his judgment, led him to lightly regard and despise the sacred, lasting blessing and live for the present with no thought for the future. The exchange means valuing present gratification and immediate satisfaction above future inheritance, durable honor, and everlasting life, a foolish bargain people will keep repeating until the end of earth's history. Once Esau understood what he had lost he bitterly regretted it and sought it with tears, but he could not regain it, warning that uncontrolled appetite can lead a person to sacrifice an eternal inheritance and heaven for temporary pleasure.

Scene and Setting

Jacob was cooking pottage when Esau came in faint from the field. That meeting set the scene for the exchange of the birthright for food. A valuable inheritance was nearly sold to meet an immediate, passing need, and hunger made Esau vulnerable to the choice. His hunger and appetite led him to treat his heavenly inheritance as worth less than immediate gratification. Uncontrolled appetite thus traded a sacred and lasting privilege for immediate gratification, sacrificing lasting blessings for perishable pleasures and warning against surrendering moral character and commitment to God for harmful desires.

Jacob had learned that God had said the elder would serve the younger. He reasoned that the promise could not be fulfilled while Esau kept the firstborn's privileges. Those privileges were honor and authority in the family and tribe next to the parents, consecration to God and selection to the priest's office, and a double portion of the father's goods. Turning Esau's faint hunger on coming in from the field to his own advantage, he proposed to feed Esau the pottage he had cooked if Esau would renounce all claim to the birthright.

Bargain and Fraud

Jacob had learned from his mother that God had said the elder would serve the younger, and he reasoned that the promise could not be fulfilled while Esau kept the firstborn's privileges of honor and authority in the family and tribe next to the parents, consecration to God and selection to the priest's office, and a double portion of the father's goods. When Esau came in faint from the field and Jacob was cooking pottage, Jacob turned that faint hunger to his own advantage to obtain the birthright. He used Esau's urgent immediate need to bargain, offering to feed him the pottage he had cooked if Esau would renounce all claim as firstborn and give up his claim in exchange. Esau, faint with hunger, sold his birthright to Jacob, lightly regarding it, and he confirmed the sale with an oath.

Jacob's attempt to gain the birthright in this way was an attempt to gain what was already his by God's promise, yet he resorted to fraud to secure it. His actions in doing so brought his brother's hatred upon him. His sin in obtaining the birthright by fraud was repented of before his night of wrestling, when he pleaded for mercy. That repentance and his trust in God's mercy enabled him to seek deliverance with confidence, and God mercifully preserved his life.

Despising Sacred Birthright

Esau came in faint with a hunger sharpened by long indulgence, for a strong appetite strengthened by repeated self-indulgence had grown until appetite and inclination ruled him and overpowered his judgment. Desire controlled him in that hour, and walking unguarded he sold his soul, his peace and his integrity for gratification of appetite and selfish advantage. Ruled by appetite and indifferent to divine blessings and requirements, he lightly regarded the birthright and treated the sacred, lasting blessing as worthless and no longer sacred. He valued present relief and immediate satisfaction above sacred privilege and the service of his Master, living for the present with no thought for the future. In letting appetite prevail he virtually despised God and heaven, counting his heavenly inheritance and the redemption purchased by Christ as of little value, which makes him a profane person.

The heavenly heirship he despised was purchased by Christ and promised only to the self-denying and God-fearing, yet self-gratification made temporary pleasure seem more desirable than that birthright. He recklessly traded it away, assuming he could later buy it back and recover it. The pottage stands for a passing appetite or advantage for which a person foolishly sells what is precious and of lasting worth. The verse therefore means valuing present gratification, relief, worldly advantage and immediate satisfaction above future inheritance, durable honor, enduring riches and everlasting life, trading everlasting life and heaven for immediate worldly desire. People will continue to make that exchange of a valuable inheritance for temporary appetite or gain until the end of earth's history.

Too Late for Recovery

Esau came in faint and traded his birthright for a dish of food, treating a sacred and lasting blessing as worthless because long-indulged appetite had overpowered his judgment and appetite and inclination ruled him. He acted selfishly and profanely, selling his soul, his peace, and his integrity for gratification of appetite and selfish advantage, walking unguarded into Satan's snare for one morsel of meat. He did so recklessly, assuming he could later buy it back and recover it at will. Once he understood what he had lost, after his desire was gratified, he bitterly regretted despising the blessing, repented with tears and sought it carefully when he would have inherited the blessing, but he was rejected and could not regain it. The Lord had removed it from him, and the loss was irreversible, a warning that a person may throw away a religious inheritance for a temporary price and find it gone forever. The same danger threatens anyone who does a selfish act, even those who know present truth and whose names are registered on church books, which demands diligent and not listless or indolent care with close inspection of motives, actions, and daily influence lest many be defiled.

His grief over despising and selling his birthright was sorrow over the unexpected consequences of his sin, not true repentance.

As Esau awoke to see the folly of his rash exchange when too late to recover his loss, so in the day of God those who have bartered their heirship to eternal life for selfish gratification will awake too late. A person with a divided heart who yields service and affections to another than God sells away his spiritual inheritance even while for a time professing godliness and appearing as a shepherd. Unless he puts on Christ and puts away idols and the indulgence of selfish passions and lusts he becomes unfaithful to his solemn trust and finally something else than a faithful child of God, for he that does the will of God abides forever, but the birthright once sold for indulgence leaves repentance coming too late.

Warnings for Present Life

The faint hunger that drove the exchange stands as a warning that appetite can lead to spiritual loss, for uncontrolled appetite can cause a person to trade a sacred and lasting privilege for immediate gratification. To surrender a birthright for food is to treat a heavenly inheritance as worth less than immediate relief, sacrificing an eternal inheritance and heaven for temporary pleasures, worldly gain, and perishable pleasures. One who throws away a religious inheritance for a temporary price may find the loss irreversible, seeking it afterward with tears yet unable to regain it.

It exposes professed Christians who cling to health-destroying indulgences that weaken the mind and benumb the soul, who are offended by the duty to be cleansed from all defilement of flesh and spirit and to be made holy, and who turn from eternal life because the way is strait. Multitudes are still selling their birthright for mere temporary, weakening and debasing sensual pleasure at the cost of health, mental strength, and heaven. The lesson is to deny harmful desires rather than surrender moral character and commitment to God, and it applies directly to intemperate habits and excessive indulgence.

Many now repeat the choice by holding fast to earthly treasures and withholding from God the tithes and offerings that belong to Him, thus selling their birthright to eternal life for money and worldly advantage. A covetous spirit that values money above spiritual responsibility, greed for money, love of display, and spending money on display rather than what nourishes the soul repeat the exchange. Giving up personal stewardship by entrusting money to another to use as they please repeats it as well. Youth waste the inheritance God has given them and betray sacred interests entrusted to them for humanity's blessing when they give in to appetite and greed.

Selling the birthright for a mess of pottage means sacrificing spirituality and eternal life for position, worldly honor, and the praise of men. It trades durable honor, enduring riches, and everlasting life for temporary self-exaltation, yielding to a tempting bribe of honor with motives not single to God's glory. Avoiding it requires humbling the heart, seeing the danger, making a strong determined effort for everlasting life, and being willing to make any and every sacrifice to gain it. A person who becomes absorbed in education and neglects prayer, religious duties, and responsibility for immediate but lesser interests is selling a birthright for a mess of pottage.

Giving up the birthright represents choosing the friendship of the Lord's enemies over faithfulness to God. Like the hungry trader of something precious for immediate self-gratification, a man gives up loyalty to God and the Sabbath to obtain a wife. Selling the birthright for a mess of pottage means yielding to impulse and unconsecrated passion by choosing an unbeliever for a wife and yielding up the claims of God, promising to give up the Sabbath to gain consent to marry. It is choosing between God and the wife by becoming disloyal to God, selling the Lord in a very cheap market, bringing the reproach of disloyalty upon the Christian life, bringing unhappiness into the family, and imperilling the soul by buying the wife. The woman who trusts her life to such a man will never feel the respect for him that a woman ought to feel for her husband.

Bartering the soul for a mess of pottage means choosing financial advantage or revenge at the cost of faithfulness to God and His people, becoming a traitor. It is turning from God for the sake of self and establishing idol self in the heart to worship at its shrine. Self magnified leaves no room for Jesus and no room for light, love, meekness and lowliness of heart, departs from the living God for a cheap price, and sets before the seller life or death. A person with a divided heart yielding service and affections to another than God sells away his spiritual inheritance even while for a time professing godliness and appearing as a shepherd. Unless he puts on Christ and puts away idols and the indulgence of selfish passions and lusts he becomes unfaithful to his solemn trust and finally something else than a faithful child of God, for he that does the will of God abides forever.

He sold his soul, his peace, and his integrity for gratification of appetite and selfish advantage and walked unguarded into Satan's snare. The same danger threatens anyone who does a selfish act, including those who know present truth and whose names are registered on church books. This demands diligent, not listless or indolent, care and close inspection of motives, actions, and daily influence lest many be defiled. Many sell their soul for a mess of pottage when they take daily steps for worldly gain that result in the loss of their souls. To lose the soul for such a price means more than personal ruin, for words, example, and evil-spun theories lead others into perplexity and difficulty, drawing men away from Christ to rank under the black banner of the prince of darkness. Such a one becomes a soul-slayer who destroys the principles God has commanded to live and destroys souls Christ came to save, when the result of life day by day should be to heal, not bruise, and to save, not destroy.

The only hope for one who has sold eternal interests for a cheap price is to repent, be converted, renew the covenant at the cross of Calvary, cleanse the soul-temple of moral defilement, let the Spirit of God supply the vacuum, die to self and crucify self and choose to serve the Lord, or lose that life which measures with the life of God. It is far better to weaken love for earthly treasure and lay up treasure in heaven in harmony with God. A person must not sell the soul or its hope of heaven for a mess of pottage by choosing worldly advantage over right principles and eternal life.