Isaiah 58:5
Is it such a fast that I have chosen? a day for a man to afflict his soul? is it to bow down his head as a bulrush, and to spread sackcloth and ashes under him? wilt thou call this a fast, and an acceptable day to the LORD? Is it such a fast that I have chosen? a day for a man to afflict his soul? is it to bow down his head as a bulrush, and to spread sackcloth and ashes under him? wilt thou call this a fast, and an acceptable day to the LORD?
The verse questions whether merely setting aside a day to torment the body, droop the head like a reed, and lie in sackcloth and ashes is the fast God has chosen and a day He accepts. Outward humiliation alone does not make worship acceptable to Him. It is especially rejected when joined to selfish pleasure, oppression, extortion, and quarreling and strife, and such empty ceremony without a changed heart cannot earn His favor or make prayer heard on high. The fast He chooses instead is practical justice and mercy — freeing the oppressed, breaking every yoke, feeding the hungry, housing the homeless poor, clothing the naked, and caring for one's own kin. Only this way of mercy joined to a broken and obedient heart opens the promised blessing of light, healing, righteousness going before, God's glory behind, and answered prayer.
Language and Imagery
The question is whether merely setting apart a day to afflict the soul can be the fast that is chosen, and whether bowing the head like a bulrush or reed and spreading sackcloth and ashes underneath can be called a fast and an acceptable day to the Lord. The answer given is no: outward humiliation of that kind, by itself, is not the chosen fast, gives no pleasure, and is not acceptable worship. Such fasting does not become acceptable simply because people humble themselves outwardly, bow their heads, and put on the dress of mourning. When joined to unrighteous dealing, seeking own pleasure, exacting labor, and fasting for strife, debate, and violent wickedness, it will not cause the voice to be heard on high.
Bowing the head as a bulrush is the picture of outward mourning, like a band of mourners moving in a funeral train. It is also the picture of a discouraged and downcast posture, hanging the head in despair. The image is therefore turned into a call not to hang the head like a bulrush but to lift it up. The downcast one is to look to the lifted-up Saviour, trust wholly in God, and believe that He saves, however grievous the sins.
Afflicting the soul for a day means bodily humiliation and humbling of self through outward acts of self-denial. It includes going without food and abstaining from food. It also includes putting ashes on the head, wearing sackcloth, displaying sackcloth and ashes, and bowing the head.
False Fast Exposed
Outward affliction by itself is not the fast that is chosen, and a day of humbling oneself, bowing the head like a reed, and spreading sackcloth and ashes underneath does not by itself make an acceptable day to the Lord. Bodily affliction, going without food, wearing sackcloth, sitting in ashes, and bowed posture are empty display when they stand alone without the just and merciful conduct required in the surrounding verses. Such a fast joined to strife, debate, and violence is not chosen, but true fasting is shown in rejecting wickedness and relieving the oppressed and needy. The call is addressed to Sabbath-keepers claiming godliness, valuing right action above many meetings and prayers, becoming less self-caring and more benevolent toward the homeless, orphans, widows, hungry and poor, freeing the oppressed, breaking yokes and burdens.
Rejection is especially certain when worshippers in the day of fasting pursue their own pleasure and interests, exact all their labors, demand labor from others, and oppress them. Fasting amid quarreling, debate, strife, and striking with the fist of wickedness and violence conceals spiritual failure and is not acceptable. The complaint that God has ignored and has not noticed such fasting is misplaced and exposes empty worship, for the answer exposes self-interest, labor demands, strife, and violence instead of freeing the oppressed, breaking burdens, and caring for the hungry, poor, and naked. Pretended mourning and religious ceremony without a sincere heart cannot win His notice.
Ritual humility without a changed heart is pretense and false humility rather than true devotion or true religion. Bowing the head, putting on an appearance of great devotion, needless mourning, afflicting the body, and spreading sackcloth and ashes are a mockery when people remain unjust, selfish, oppressive, unrepentant, and unchanged in heart. What is lacking is repentance, meekness and lowliness, grace, sincere inward humbleness, and faith working through love, and ceremonies cannot earn favor while oppression continues. This rebukes those who seek God daily and delight in outward ordinances, forms, and ceremonies while having forsaken God, a condition seen in the priests and Pharisees who thought outward worship would commend them to Christ. The acceptable way instead is humbling the heart before God, accepting reproof, truly repenting, putting away sin, seeking pardon, and doing stern practical work of righteousness in kindness to the needy, clothing the naked, relieving the oppressed, and bringing sinners to repentance rather than advancing self and neglecting simple duties.
Such a fast does not cause the voice to be heard on high, does not win God's notice, does not recommend a person to God, and does not commend outward worship to Christ. Those who find fault because He does not see their afflicting of soul and does not give all they desire are told they do not deserve what they require, because they have not dealt righteously but find pleasure, exact labor, fast for strife and debate, and strike with wickedness. False fasting is high profession of piety and much outward exactness bound up with great inward wickedness, complaining that services go unnoticed, which expresses hearts unsubdued by grace and rebellious against the truth. A fast pleasing to God is joined to keeping His commandments, loving His law, yielding mind, heart, and will to Him, receiving truth that works by love and purifies the soul, honoring Him by obedience to His holy, just, and good law, and relieving those who suffer in harmony with Him.
True Fast Required
The fast that is chosen is not a day of outward humiliation alone, but practical justice and mercy in place of it. It is to loose the bands of wickedness, to undo heavy burdens rather than bind them on, to let the oppressed go free, and to break every yoke. It is to deal bread to the hungry, to bring the homeless poor who are cast out into the house, to cover the naked, and not to hide from one's own flesh or kin. Such outward show joined with pursuing one's own interests, exacting labor, quarreling and debate, and smiting with the fist of wickedness to make the voice heard on high is not accepted and is not called a fast or an acceptable day to the Lord. Those who claim to do righteousness must help needy people they meet, especially believers suffering for the truth, rather than restricting aid to relatives and friends, and neglect brings accountability to God.
Acceptable worship requires humbling the heart before God with a broken and contrite spirit instead of mere bodily humiliation, appearance of devotion, needless mourning, and afflicting the body. It is worship in spirit and in truth brought into life and character, expressing itself in surrender of self and willing service to God and others wherever His people are. It is stern practical work of righteousness — showing kindness to the needy, clothing the naked, relieving the oppressed and suffering, bringing sinners to repentance with full purpose of heart, and turning from advancing self, oppressing others, and neglecting the simple duties of life. It is joined to keeping His commandments, loving His law, doing justice, mercy and truth, and revealing Him through life and actions in harmony with God, which includes giving up passions and practices that weaken character such as tobacco use.
Only after these works of mercy and necessity comes the promise. Then light breaks forth as the morning, health springs forth speedily for body and soul, righteousness goes before, and the glory of the Lord is the rereward. That means putting the precepts of the law into practice with the righteousness of Christ as frontguard and God's glory as rearward, while being God's helping hand in a time of confusion, violence, murder, theft, and crime. Faithful work to benefit and bless others brings answered prayer, a sense of satisfaction, peace in the soul of more value than gold, spiritual health and joyful experience, a remedy for sickness, despondency, evil surmisings and harmful speech, and blessing registered in the books of heaven with more than an earthly reward.
All praying and abstinence from food avail nothing unless joined to resolute practical mercy. Souls seeking the Lord are to leave mere outward humiliation alone and instead do daily practical kindness to bless the afflicted around them, for that meets the requirements of God. That work requires not waiting for the poor to come and plead, but searching for them, sympathizing with them, and relieving them, especially taking destitute fatherless and motherless children, widows, the homeless, the hungry, the naked, and one's own flesh into care. It requires taking hold of God's saving arm by faith with one hand while relieving the oppressed with the other hand of love, for no one can hold God while using the other hand to serve self-pleasure.
Historical Setting
The chapter lays out the present condition of the nation and names the cause of its calamity. The people have forsaken and forgotten God, have chosen other gods and followed their own corrupt ways until He has turned from them. The inhabitants of the earth have trampled upon His law and broken His everlasting covenant, and have despised His Sabbath.
Outward mourning and self-affliction, bowing the head, wearing sackcloth and sitting in ashes, do not by themselves make a fast acceptable to God. A national fast that asks Him to end a war while the people preserve slavery and mistreat the oppressed is an insult to Him. Acceptable fasting must be joined to freeing the oppressed and breaking their yokes.
The question exposes a people who seek God daily and delight in outward ordinances, forms and ceremonies while having forsaken Him and lacking meekness and lowliness. He does not choose and takes no pleasure in a fast that is only affliction of soul and bodily humiliation, and such a display is not an acceptable day to Him and will not cause the voice to be heard on high. That same condition was found in the priests and Pharisees in Christ's day, who thought their outward worship would commend them to Christ. The chapter is a trumpet call for the present time and for people living in the present age, to show God's people their transgressions and the house of Jacob their sins, and its warning is to be fulfilled. Outward religious observance must not conceal transgression or sin, but God's people are to recognize and forsake their transgressions and become morally and spiritually pure. Every soul is enjoined to receive Bible truth enthroned in the heart, with individual souls at stake in receiving it, and that enthroned truth alone keeps the heart with all diligence against Satan's working with all deceivableness of unrighteousness, against judgment blinded by appetite and passion in lawyers, judges, juries, parliaments and councils, and against blind ministers who are leaders of the blind, answering the question What is truth pressed by the times in which we now live, by eternal realities, and by pure and undefiled religion.
Prophecy and Sabbath Reform
The whole chapter, and this verse in it, belongs to God's people at this time and in the last days, to Sabbath-keepers professing godliness, and its warning is to be fulfilled now while time is passing rapidly. It is a trumpet call for the present time to show God's people their transgressions and the house of Jacob their sins, exposing those who seek God daily and appear devoted while turning away from Him, whose outward observance must not conceal transgression and sin. With Isaiah 55 and Isaiah 56 and the rest of Isaiah 58 it calls God's people to arouse themselves to give the last note of warning to save a perishing world. That work is bound up with doing the beneficence God requires in practical help for the needy, with keeping His commandments especially the seventh-day Sabbath, and with repairing the breach made in His law. It enjoins every soul to receive Bible truth enthroned in the heart, with individual souls at stake in receiving it, for that enthroned truth alone keeps the heart with all diligence against Satan working with all deceivableness of unrighteousness, against judgment blinded by appetite and passion in lawyers, judges, juries, parliaments and councils, and against blind ministers as leaders of the blind, answering the question What is truth pressed by the times, by eternal realities, and by pure and undefiled religion.
The chapter marks out a right course and a wrong course with assurance of blessing for following the right. The wrong course is the faults condemned in ancient Israel, to be avoided by taking up the duties close at hand, and the right course is carried out in calm, unwavering trust in Him who is the Way, the Truth, and the Life. In the last days that right course is the appointed work of building the old waste places and restoring right paths. Mere outward acts of fasting — afflicting oneself, bowing the head, wearing sackcloth and ashes — do not by themselves make a fast chosen by God or acceptable to Him, and the chapter instead calls for the duties and principles He requires, including repairing the breach in His law. It is God's message to His people to make up the breach that the man of sin has made in the law of God, a work that brings souls to conversion under the power of God. Its first part contains this rebuke of false fasting, while its last part requires repairing the breach made in the law of God and raising up the foundations of many generations by keeping the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, with rich blessings reacting back upon those who bless others.
The breach is the exalting of a spurious Sabbath instead of the Sabbath of Jehovah. The duty is to stand for the seventh day when laws compel all to observe the first day of the week instead of the seventh, meeting that coming trouble without stirring up contention among those who profess to keep God's commandments. Upon those who keep the Sabbath of the Lord it lays the responsibility of a work of mercy and benevolence, with medical missionary work and the gospel ministry bound together as the message is given to the world and sealed with the seal of God. It speaks to those who turn away their feet from the Sabbath, the Sabbath of Exodus 31 which is a sign between God and His people, and keeping this day holy shows to the world recognition of God as the One who created the world in six days and rested on the seventh, calling for earnestly and untiringly bearing the message lest time pass and people be left unwarned. The same call summons Sabbathkeepers to renewed conversion and more faithful Sabbath observance, confessing neglect and lack of reverence shown by bringing ordinary work, words, and unsanctified thoughts into the Sabbath.
The chapter represents the proclamation of the Sabbath truth with a loud voice, clearly and distinctly, earnestly and decidedly. The Sabbath question is not to be approached by gradual preparation or by beating about the bush. It is the proclamation of the third angel's message, to be given in this direct manner at camp meetings, with the trumpet giving a certain sound. Its proclamation is empowered by the Holy Spirit, and its impact is proportionate to the earnestness with which it is given. The question whether bowing the head and wearing sackcloth and ashes is a chosen fast and an acceptable day is applied in connection with keeping the Sabbath and not robbing God in tithes and offerings. Its call belongs to a life of genuine piety: putting away sin, living in obedience, and keeping the Sabbath faithfully.
Doctrine and Spiritual Experience
Outward fasting with bowed heads, sackcloth and ashes does not make a fast acceptable to God, for ritual display and self-affliction are not the humility He values, especially when joined to strife, oppression and unkindness. Such false fasting is high profession of piety and much outward exactness bound up with great inward wickedness, complaining that God lets its services go unnoticed, which is the expression of hearts unsubdued by grace and rebellious against the truth. The fast He chooses instead is practical, to break wickedness and burdens and free the oppressed. Such service does not earn salvation, but living faith in God leads people to work as Christ did and to show His character. The spirit of true fasting and prayer yields mind, heart and will to God, receiving the truth which works by love and purifies the soul, in loyalty to God and obedience to His law, which is holy and just and good.
Outward show joined with fasting for strife and debate and to smite with the fist of wickedness in order to make the voice heard on high is not accepted. The fast chosen instead is to loose the bands of wickedness, to undo heavy burdens rather than bind them on, to let the oppressed go free, to break every yoke, to share bread with the hungry, to house the poor who are cast out, to cover the naked, and not to hide from one's own flesh. Only after doing these works of mercy and necessity comes the promise that light breaks forth as the morning, health springs forth speedily, righteousness goes before, and the glory of the Lord is the rereward. That righteousness is the imputed righteousness of Jesus Christ, going as frontguard before those who put the precepts of the law into practice, while God's glory is rearward. In this way His people become His helping hand in a time of confusion, violence, murder, theft and crime.
Reading and practicing the chapter teaches how to pray in the Spirit instead of offering formal, empty or set prayers, from loving God with heart and soul and mind and strength and loving neighbor as self. It condemns fasting joined to strife, violence and the desire to make one's voice heard by God, showing that outward acts of self-denial by themselves do not make a fast acceptable to the Lord. True fasting is personal seeking of God through earnest prayer and study of His Word. Such sincere, wholehearted worship calls for prayer shaped by a sincere heart and the Holy Spirit, not empty forms. Prayers formed in this way bear evidence of divine prompting and will be heard and answered.
The chapter gives a sure remedy for poor health, calling for self-denial that turns from personal wants toward meeting others' needs and supporting God's work. Turning over the picture to God's plan, the fast chosen is unselfish brotherhood instead of self-centered ideas and plans, relieving the necessities of those who need help instead of hiding from them. This course brings the breaking forth as the morning with the glory of God as rearward, as a remedy for sickness, despondency, evil surmisings and harmful speech. True religion requires obedience to the laws of the physical organism, so the fast chosen does not include ruining health by continual taxation and overexertion. God has fixed a limit to self-denying, self-sacrificing effort and does not require presumption that weakens the physical machinery, for such a course does not glorify Him and is not acceptable to Him, since the mind cannot act healthfully when the body is weakened.
Wise use of strength therefore means studying the laws of health, reasoning in work, taking judicious exercise and care of powers today to be fitted for the labors of tomorrow, preserving the life God has given, refusing to labor to exhaustion or to crowd two days' work into one, and keeping a reserve for other duties and times of need. The verse lays a work on every soul claiming to share the divine nature to rid the soul of everything like selfishness, for God will not acknowledge a claim to great things when selfishness thread after thread is woven into the life. It must be seen and stayed wide awake to observe, thread by thread removed. The verse belongs to warning and instruction that points out the evil and the remedy for the diseased soul, calling for decided, deep and thorough reformation and change, not only among the young but among instructors of the young.
It depicts people who need to repent and humble themselves before God, afflicting their souls rather than continuing in wrongdoing. Those addressed are called to recognize their errors and the harm they have done to themselves and others, and to contemplate Christ's humiliation and suffering as they repent. It is a reproof calling for true repentance in which people put away their sins and seek pardon.
Practical Obedience
The chapter opens a wide field of practical service to be done now to prepare people for the Lord's great day, for outward fasting and religious display do not by themselves make a fast acceptable to God. Right action is valued above numerous meetings and prayers, with less self-caring and more benevolence toward the needy, including the homeless, orphans, and widows. Its message is given to gain physical and spiritual strength through personal help for children, youth, widows, orphans, the aged, the infirm, the sick, the wounded, the suffering, and others in need, rather than neglecting those responsibilities. This ministry brings life to the churches, carried out through generosity and labor, helping people who suffer and feeding the hungry in following Christ's benevolent ministry. The directions join true worship with relieving distressed families and giving special help to those cast out or suffering because they courageously accepted the truth.
The fast God chooses is expressed in action: loosening wickedness and burdens, freeing the oppressed, breaking every yoke, feeding the hungry, sheltering the homeless poor, clothing the naked, and caring for one's own kin. Those who claim to do righteousness must help needy people they encounter, especially believers suffering for the truth, rather than restricting aid to relatives and friends, and neglecting this duty brings accountability to God. The work is done by personal effort, self-denial and self-sacrifice, denying personal wants and giving up luxuries and needless ornaments to relieve those in need, make suffering people comfortable, and support God's work. It advances God's truth by providing workers with means and facilities to reach new places and people who have not heard the message. Believers are not to sit Sabbath after Sabbath merely listening to preaching, but to visit friends, neighbors, and families, create interest in present truth, plant the Word in many hearts, deal out the bread of life to hungering souls, and lift up Christ together with God for the salvation and conversion of souls.
Talents are committed to each to be used for His glory, with the world as the vineyard and soil in every city and village, in highways and byways, near and afar off, where seed is to be sown in good works that benefit those without the light of present truth. Those arrayed in Christ's righteousness and sanctified by truth labor for all classes with equal solicitude, not bound by selfishness, regarding all the world as the field, letting light shine without limit to regions beyond, teaching the word to unbelievers and uniting in prayer for them as duties owed to the Redeemer. Its application is a Christlike, unselfish life that helps others and brings praise and thanksgiving to God, set against selfishness and covetousness which are idolatry. Ministry to suffering people and bringing God's truth to the world are not to be separated, but are clearly joined as two lines of work.
Medical missionary work and the gospel ministry are to be bound together as the message is given to the world, bound up with the message and sealed with the seal of God. This includes caring for the sick through small sanitariums connected with schools and teaching students to use nature's simple remedies under the direction of Jesus Christ. Its principles are to be visible in the conduct of those who have accepted the truth, including in medical institutions and the treatment of patients, putting merely theoretical belief into practical faith and works in medical missionary service and educating workers to serve the Lord. God's people and institutions are to set things in order and put His principles into practice, rather than rely on fasting and prayer while serving selfish purposes, and its sacred influence is to be preserved in institutional work including sanitariums. Those who abide in Christ by eating the bread of life do individual Christian work without faultfinding, and in doing it have a healthy, growing experience with righteousness going before them.
The instruction includes breaking yokes that hinder the Lord's servants and prevent them from acting in harmony with the light God gives. God does not accept outward observance joined with dishonest transaction, robbery and extortion, and Sabbathkeepers are to follow the true fast by cleansing marketplaces, courts, lawyers' offices and the medical fraternity from fraud and refusing all dishonest dealing, revealing the Father's tender compassion by healing as Christ did. The soul who keeps the Sabbath bears the sign of God's government and must not dishonor that sign by unjust gain. Restaurant work must not become so enlarged that those who should be giving the gospel to souls starving for the bread of life are occupied in serving tables. The chapter is God's remedy for selfishness in the church, calling His people to cooperate in saving souls and to serve others and work for the saving of souls.
Leaders and people connected with institutions are urged to study it, because reproofs have been disregarded and some have accepted only parts of His word rather than making thorough consecration to God. It rebukes unchristlike conduct whose quarrels and pride dishonored the truth, drove people apart, and turned outsiders away, exposing a course separated from Christ that outward religious practice could not make acceptable. Those who live in Christ and receive the light of God are to carry out the work specified. The chapter contains life and light, goodness and truth in words of warning and encouragement to be received and applied to individual life, bringing light, life, goodness and truth to those who practice it. Faithful work to benefit and bless others brings satisfaction, creates peace in the soul of more value than gold, stands registered in heaven with more than earthly reward, and fulfills the sacred duty to receive God's grace in order to give it to others.
It repays reading over many times with deeper impression each time for believers fitting themselves to work for the Master so truth may go forth as a burning lamp. It is profitable to commit to memory and repeat when tempted, walling the soul with restriction and instruction, supplying the answer It is written when the mind is led to earthly and sensual things, and supplying clear evidence that those who keep the commandments and the faith of Jesus are the people God is leading and preparing by tests to stand in the great day. With Isaiah 55, 56, and 57 it stands as a field of comfort and encouragement, showing an open door where God can be met and found, requiring the meekness Christ lived, a humbled heart before God, and right relation to Him. Its message can lead hearers to keep the Lord's Sabbath, trust God through trials, and share the light of truth with others, while the fashion of this world passes away.
One application directs benevolent work toward helping people who accept the truth and need practical care, and does not justify spending resources on work that fails to strengthen faithful workers and those in need. In that application the chapter is said not to support spending resources on the slum population targeted by such work, but to direct help toward people converted through the truth who keep the commandments and need support. Another application teaches true worship as practical care for the poor and suffering, with the church caring for needy members including orphans and the aged and not passing them by, giving up luxuries and ornaments to make them comfortable. Help in that application is to be offered wisely, especially in ways enabling people to help themselves, and may extend beyond the household of faith to others suitable to receive it.